Tax Control Framework

IPSOA INTERNATIONAL TAXATION

Tax Control Framework

Governance and Management Models for Cooperative Compliance

In an increasingly demanding global environment, where transparency and accountability are central to the expectations of investors, regulators and civil society, companies can no longer afford to view taxation as a purely technical and administrative matter. Tax governance is increasingly emerging as a strategic pillar for ensuring not only regulatory compliance, but also the creation of sustainable and lasting value.
The book “Tax Control Framework: Governance and Management Models for Cooperative Compliance” provides an in-depth exploration of how taxpayers can transform tax risk into an opportunity for growth and strengthen stakeholder confidence through a structured and innovative approach. With a focus on the most modern tax risk management tools, including in particular the Tax Control Framework, the book is aimed at all business operators and provides practical suggestions and insights for building an integrated tax risk management system in line with international best practices, taking into account recent regulatory developments in this area.

The Scientific Committee:

• Paolo Bertoli
• Roberto Betti
• Massimo Boidi
• Giorgio Bonanno
• Gianluca Campana
• Cristina Caraccioli
• Danilo Massimo Cardone
• Filipa Correia
• Manlio Del Giudice
• Elbano de Nuccio
• Annibale Dodero
• Gianfranco Ferranti
• Carlo Garbarino
• Tamara Gasparri
• Paola Monica Giachetto
• Stefano Giuliano
• Giampiero Ianni
• Aleksandar Ivanovski
• Fabrizia Lapecorella
• Gerardo Longobardi
• Antonella Magliocco
• Francesca Mariotti
• Agostino Nuzzolo
• Stella Raventós-Calvo
• Raffaele Rizzardi
• Franco Roccatagliata
• Vincenzo Scotti
• Alberto Trabucchi
• Ivan Vacca
• Piergiorgio Valente
• Federico Vincenti
• Luigi Vinciguerra
• Paolo Zanenga

Fiscal Governance Framework

Tax Risk Management

Implementation of internal systems to identify and mitigate tax risks.

Collaborative Compliance

Promoting trust and communication between tax authorities and taxpayers.

Tax Control Framework

Integrated system for the management and control of tax risks.

2023 Tax Reform

Legislative improvements to strengthen cooperative compliance.

TCF Certification

Professional certification to ensure compliance and credibility.

Overview

This paper examines the development and implementation of the Cooperative Compliance regime in Italy, placing it within the broader context of tax governance and tax risk management. It highlights the shift from purely regulatory tax compliance to a strategic dimension for businesses, which requires the adoption of internal control systems (Tax Control Framework – TCF) and a collaborative approach with the tax authorities.
The scheme aims to establish a relationship of trust between the tax authorities and the taxpayer, increasing certainty on relevant tax matters through constant and proactive dialogue.

Main Topics

• Tax Governance and Tax Risk Management: The importance for businesses, particularly multinationals, of implementing internal control systems to identify, map, monitor and manage tax risks. This is not only to ensure compliance, but also to optimise the tax burden and prevent disputes with the tax authorities. Tax risk management must balance the maximisation of business opportunities with the prudent management of the risks associated with them.
• Cooperative Compliance Regime: The key mechanism introduced by Legislative Decree No. 128 of 5 August 2015, with the aim of strengthening the relationship of trust between the tax authorities and the taxpayer. It is based on proactive dialogue and the sharing of assessments of situations likely to give rise to tax risks.
• Tax Control Framework (TCF): An integrated system for the identification, measurement,
management and control of tax risk, a key element for participation in the cooperative compliance scheme. It must ensure the identification, assessment and management of tax risks, both compliance-related and interpretative.
• Role of the 2023 Tax Reform: The Enabling Act for tax reform No. 111/2023 has
introduced significant changes to the cooperative compliance regime, aiming to enhance it, lower the threshold for access, extend it to groups of companies and strengthen the incentives.
• TCF Certification: The introduction, via Ministerial Decree No. 212/2024 (“Certifiers Decree”),
of the possibility for qualified professionals (solicitors and accountants registered on specific lists) to certify the TCF, subject to specific requirements regarding integrity and professionalism. This certification may be invoked before the tax authorities.

Key Reference Documents Cited

• Legislative Decree No. 128 of 5 August 2015 (Legal Certainty Decree)
• Law No. 111/2023 (Enabling Act for Tax Reform)
• Decree of the Ministry of Economy and Finance of 29 April 2024 (Code of Conduct)
• Revenue Agency Provision No. 5320/2025 of 10 January 2025 (Guidelines for the preparation of the TCF)
• Decree of the Minister of Economy and Finance No. 126 of 31 July 2024 (Regulations on Guided Voluntary Disclosure)
• Decree of the Minister of Economy and Finance of 6 December 2024 (Procedures for the application of the cooperative compliance regime)
• Decree of the Ministry of Economy and Finance No. 212 of 12 November 2024 (Certifiers Decree)
• Circular of the Revenue Agency No. 38/E of 16 September 2016 (Clarifications on the cooperative compliance regime)
• Resolution of the Revenue Agency No. 49/E of 22 July 2021 (Further clarifications)

Key Ideas and Facts

Evolution of Tax Compliance:
Tax compliance is no longer just a regulatory obligation, but a strategic dimension requiring adequate internal control systems capable of mapping, monitoring, and managing tax risks and a collaborative and proactive approach with tax authorities.

Objective of the Cooperative Compliance Regime:
To establish a relationship of trust between the Tax Administration and the taxpayer aimed at increasing certainty on relevant tax matters through constant and preventive dialogue.

Subjective Requirements for Access (Art. 7 of Legislative Decree No. 128/2015, as amended by the 2023 Enabling Law):

Size Threshold: Turnover or revenues not less than:
€750 million starting from 2024

€500 million starting from 2026

€100 million starting from 2028

Group Membership: Access is allowed for companies not meeting the size requirements if they belong to a group with at least one qualifying entity and if the group adopts an integrated and centrally managed Tax Control Framework (TCF).

New Investment Ruling: Access is independent of turnover for companies implementing positive responses issued by the Revenue Agency to advance ruling requests on new investments.
Tax Control Framework (TCF) Requirements:
A valid TCF must include (as per the Guidelines of January 10, 2025 – Measure No. 5320/2025):

Tax strategy.

Clear roles and responsibilities, with proper segregation of duties.

Effective procedures for identifying, measuring, managing, and controlling risks.

Continuous monitoring to detect deficiencies and errors.

Ability to adapt to internal and external changes.

Annual report to governing bodies.
Tax Risk Assessment Process:
A key element of the TCF, it identifies and evaluates tax risks, providing a mapping of risks, involved processes, and controls. It distinguishes between:

Compliance tax risks: operational risks of failing to properly meet tax obligations.

Interpretative tax risks: risks arising from uncertainty in tax law application, either abstractly or in specific cases, managed through a dedicated Interpretative Risk Management Policy.
Tax Risk and Controls Map (RCM):
A core document for regime admission, linking each relevant business process to its specific tax risks and related mitigating controls. It includes inherent and residual risk assessment, tax area mapping, and descriptions of first- and second-level controls.
Preventive Dialogue:
The heart of the regime, it entails ongoing meetings between the taxpayer and the Revenue Agency for a shared evaluation of situations potentially generating tax risks.
Cooperative Compliance Agreement:
A formal document signed by both parties, defining a shared assessment on strategic issues with significant tax implications. It binds both parties for the current and subsequent fiscal years unless material changes occur.
Duties of the Revenue Agency:
To provide timely and comprehensive responses, ensure consistency and uniformity in preventive dialogues, perform evaluations based on objectivity, reasonableness, and proportionality, and maintain strict confidentiality of information.
Duties of the Taxpayer:
To implement and maintain an effective TCF, ensure clear allocation of roles and responsibilities, promptly and thoroughly communicate any tax risks (including aggressive tax planning, regardless of materiality thresholds), respond to information requests, and establish an internal regulatory system with ethical codes and conduct guidelines considering tax compliance as a key variable.
Code of Conduct:
Approved by the Ministry of Economy and Finance (Decree of April 29, 2024), it defines mutual commitments between the Tax Administration and taxpayers. Taxpayer commitments include: refraining from investments in tax havens solely for tax savings, complying with transfer pricing regulations, and avoiding transactions that produce effects contrary to declared intent or exploit asymmetries for double deductions or non-taxation.
Incentives of the Regime:

Shorter Statute of Limitations: Two-year reduction for risks that have been communicated, applicable from the fiscal year in progress as of January 1, 2024, for already admitted participants.

Criminal Non-Punishability and Reduced Administrative Penalties: Timely communicated risks generally exempt from penalties. For “non-significant” risks included in the risk map, administrative penalties are halved, not exceeding the legal minimum. Guided voluntary disclosure (Decree No. 126 of July 31, 2024) provides simplified and faster procedures for voluntarily correcting errors or omissions.

Exemption from TCF Certification: For participants already admitted as of January 1, 2024, no independent professional certification is required.

Retroactive Effects: Taxpayers may retroactively apply the results of rulings or agreements to prior tax periods by filing amended returns or voluntary disclosures.
Duration of the Regime:
It starts from the fiscal year of application and is tacitly renewed. Exclusion may occur if TCF or subjective requirements are no longer met, relevant risks are not disclosed, or serious non-cooperative behavior undermines trust. Failure to identify a risk in good faith does not automatically trigger exclusion unless the risk’s gravity undermines the reliability of the system.
Revenue Agency Controls:
The Agency does not repeat controls already carried out during preventive dialogues unless facts change or untruthful information emerges.
Certifiers (Ministerial Decree No. 212/2024):
Lawyers and accountants listed in specific registers, with proven integrity and professional competence. They must assess whether the TCF ensures reasonable assurance regarding the conscious and reliable management of fiscal matters. The assessment involves two levels (general and specific controls) and three phases (scope definition, design evaluation, and control testing). Certifiers must attest that the TCF meets legal requirements and aligns with official Guidelines. Strict independence criteria apply.

Concluding Remarks

The cooperative compliance scheme represents a significant attempt to modernise the relationship between the tax authorities and taxpayers in Italy, shifting the emphasis from ex post control to prevention and proactive collaboration. The scheme’s success is closely linked to the effectiveness of the corporate Tax Control Framework and the ability to establish a relationship of trust based on transparency and the timely communication of risks. The recent changes introduced by the tax reform and the introduction of TCF certification by qualified professionals aim to further strengthen the scheme and encourage participation by a greater number of businesses. The emphasis on conscious tax risk management and proactivity in dialogue with the tax authorities is a distinctive feature of the new approach. Despite the implementation of an advanced TCF, the document acknowledges that it is not possible to completely eliminate errors, but only to reduce the likelihood of them occurring.