GEB_LOGO

Quotes

Transfer Pricing Phisiognomy

“All benchmarks are likely, or at least they
are so, theoretically speaking.
All benchmarks that are likely in theory are
theoretically applicable in practice.
However, not all benchmarks that are theoretically
applicable in practice are actually applicable to
all concrete cases.
What’s more: some benchmarks that are
theoretically applicable in practice may be
practically unlikely and may result as being
actually inapplicable (in some given concrete
cases).
It is up to the interpreter to be able to discern
between benchmarks that are likely from the
ones that are not, evaluate whether the ones
that are likely are possible, assess whether the
ones that are possible are likely (in specific
concrete cases).
The debate between the Tax Authorities and
Taxpayers has the purpose of establishing a level
of evident likelihood or a just as evident
unlikelihood of the benchmark.
Balance and critical judgment support the ability
to discern between what is an acceptable
likelihood from an unacceptable unlikelihood.
The crux of the problem lies precisely in such
antithetical interests that exist between the Tax
Authorities and Taxpayers to the point that the
unlikely becomes possible and the impossible
becomes likely.
Be it likely or unlikely as it may.
And to raise – with an ever-increasing likelihood –
that which is unlikely to (the heights of) that
which is possible.”

(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 1227)

Abuse of Law and Tax Avoidance

“Abuse of law is the combination of avoidance
of abuse (from taxpayer’s side) and of abuse of
avoidance (from the Revenue Office’s side).
This is the Revenue Office’s means to challenge
taxpayer’s end and taxpayer’s means to thwart
the Revenue Office’s ends.
What is – however – not acceptable is that the
ends justify the means and the means justify
the ends.
Hence, for a system to be equitable, the balance
– whether of means or ends – lies somewhere
in the middle with regard to both.
And this is its true purpose for both, ends and
means.”

(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 8-9)

International Tax Avoidance

“The transnational regulation of economic relations and the centralization of decisional powers are fundamental aspects of the political process of globalization …” 
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 138)

International Tax Avoidance

“It should be pointed out that pursuing a tax saving should not – in any way – be assimilated to tax avoidance …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 71)

International Tax Avoidance

“Tax avoidance is the “regulated” expression of the principle of law abuse, a (legal) “species” of the “genus” “immanent” in the tax system …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 492)

International Tax Avoidance

“Tax system does not intend to reward entrepreneurial choices that are not determined by a substantial economic evaluation …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 365)

International Tax Avoidance

“Avoidance behaviors generally entail and have the purpose of selecting instruments and legal institutions that allow a considerable reduction of the tax burden …” 
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 70)

International Tax Avoidance

“Tax avoidance is the “regulated” expression of the principle of law abuse, a (legal) “species” of the “genus” “immanent” in the tax system …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 492)

International Tax Avoidance

“The selling enterprise might prefer a transfer operation, while the purchaser might find it more convenient to separately buy single assets …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 389)

International Tax Avoidance

“EC jurisprudence restates the existence of a general principle prohibiting abusive practices ever since 1974 …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 319)

International Tax Avoidance

“The Tax Authorities are therefore required to adopt a most prudential approach …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 364)

International Tax Avoidance

“The market, meant as a place for exchange, becomes a “real and proper legal system” …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 137)

International Tax Avoidance

“Law abuse has always been – and still is – of interest to law in general …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 251)

International Tax Avoidance

“In order for avoidance not to occur, extraordinary operations should have a real and substantial economic motivation …”
(Piergiorgio Valente)

In International Tax Avoidance (p. 406)

Tax Quote

“What is the difference between a taxidermist and a tax collector? The taxidermist takes only your skin” (Mark Twain, Notebook, 1902)

Tax Quote

“Rightful taxation is the price of social order. In other words, it is that portion of the citizen’s property which he yields up to the government in order to provide for the protection of all the rest. It is not to be wantonly levied on the citizen, nor levied at all except in return for benefits conferred”
(Journal of the Senate of the State of Ohio: Being the First Session of the Forty-Sixth General Assembly, held in the city of Columbus, commencing on December 6, 1847, Vol. XLVI, reported by Mr. Archbold)

Tax Quote

Taxes, after all, are duties that we pay for the privileges of membership in an organized society
(Franklin D. Roosevelt)

In International Tax Avoidance

Tax Quote

“The avoidance of taxes is the only intellectual pursuit that carries any reward”
(John Maynard Keynes)

In International Tax Avoidance

Tax Quote

“There is no such thing as a good tax”
(Winston Churchill)

In International Tax Avoidance